Skip to main content

Top reasons why you should read the book before watching a film adaptation.


There's not a single person who isn't excited about a film adaptation of a favourite book. It is indeed a treat. As long as the movie stays loyal to the book, everything goes smooth, but when the diversion begins you start to fuss. It's only natural to have painted a picture of the story in your mind and to feel bothered when it goes awry. Nevertheless, the film gives you an unmatched feeling of meeting the characters and places only having read and imagined.
       'If it can be written, or thought, it can be filmed' - Stanley Kubrick.



Movies tend to skip details. 

If you are a person who gives attention to details, then the book should be your first choice. The introduction of a character and the gradual development of it can only be enjoyed when you read. In a film, the wordiness is cut short making it digestible for the impatient movie-goer.

Films are hard pressed for time.

When the story is to be given life by the director, he is up to the most challenging phase of the work. The script has to be developed so not to ruin the book-lover's imagination, and also give an impression of not missing out on the plot for the film-lover. The film has to strike a perfect balance between the two. All said and done sometimes we could see the script suffering in the hands of the director. There are some films which are true to the book frame by frame such as "Godfather".

Spoilers galore.

If you are a book-worm and intend to read a copy of a famous book which is on its way to get filmed, then you're cornered all over the social media by spoilers. So better grab a copy and finish it off quietly before looking up the film details.

Some parts get lost.

It is good to read the book whole because you may find some precious parts missing in the film. Like the scenes of Sirius Black, James Potter and Snape in Potter's legilimens class. The way you intepret a particular scene maybe different from how the tinselmen do it. So that means loss of some scenes.

To become a better judge of things.

The saying goes, "Never judge a book by it's movie". That doesn't mean that you shouldn't judge the movie by the book. You have all rights to judge the movie as a reviewer and weigh the chances of it over the book.

A film adaptation can always be compared to the idiom, "tip of the iceberg". Here is a list of my favourite book to movie adaptations,


  • Emma 2009 (mini series)
  • Harry Potter and the Philosopher's stone
  • Pride and Prejudics (2005)
  • Sense and Sensibility (1995)
  • The Other Boleyn Girl
  • Mystic River

There is one adaptation which surpassed the books,

Sherlock Holmes Part 1 & 2.
By Guy Ritchie.

Well according to me, this particular film deserves huge adulation.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Simple, yet poignant lyrics (II)

I've got a knack of discovering pleasant songs, excellent movies, endearing books very late in time, sometimes even after it's fad fades away. One such song is Perunthil nee enaku... The beauty of this song is that it relates to some very simple, unnoticed but pleasing moments in a our day to day life. The duet is of two people who sing about  what they mean to each other. There are some cute imperfections in Madhushri's tamil pronunciation but the male singer makes up for all that. Duh! Why do I even have to annotate the lyrics? It speaks for itself. ;) Perunthil nee enaku jannal oram Pin vasal mutrathil ne tulasi madam Vidumurai natkalil pallikoodam Vilayattu pillaigalin chella kobam Aalilla nalliravil ketkum padal Anbe anbe neeye (hmmm....) Payanathil varugira siru thookam Paruvathil mulaikira muthal koocham Paritchaiku padikira athikalai Kazhuthinil vizhundhidum mudhal maalai Pughaipadam edukkayil thinarum punnagai Anbe anbe neethane Adai

Quote Wonderment (I)

I'm totally sick of examinations and stuff. World's worst stressors are exams. I've always had this opinion right from my childhood. Hmmm... So to get a break I was running through my old memories and thoughts. One such is the admiration for this quote, "Sometimes people are beautiful. Not in looks. Not in what they say. Just in what they are." --Markus Zusak The quote itself is amazing. Reminds me of so many things. And note that Markus Zusak's wonderful book called 'The Book Thief' which was a good read. Laziness blocks me from writing more. ;)

2 States - Oh please, no!

I don't know why I chose to read '2 States' over 'The Subtle Knife'. My copy of 'Subtle Knife' is sleeping in the shelf. I wish I had finished it off instead of reading this one. M' Okay let me tell why this book was so insipid, [beware of spoilers hehe!] Possible reasons why I picked up this book: 1. Thought it would be a light-read. 2. It involved IIM A 3. Curiosity to know the speciality of Tamil girls 4. Heard it is a slapstick comedy [ which is not, in any way] Top reasons why I disliked it: 1. Cliched plot with stale scenes. [Ithellam nanga 'Poovellam Kettupar' la ye pathutomm, Chetan!!] 2. Making fun of South-Indians went overboard. [where Punjabis were never hurt in any dialogues, a very feeble mocking was clear] 3. Nothing less than a Bollywood drama, too filmy! 4. Totally predictable. 5. Ananya herself [there're are a multitude of reasons to hate her, which I won't enumerate here] 6. The feeling of reading his p